Pipe Dreams and Racist Rhetoric


Posted on September 27th, by Joy Brown in Joy Brown. No Comments

old plumbing pipesI know the distinctive sound of my gurgling pipes, and I dread it. My plumbing stopped working several times until I finally spent thousands to remedy the problem. I realized I had been taking first world, water-related tasks for granted, such as showering and brushing my teeth anytime I felt like it.

It was therefore a relief to get back to my former rhetorically provoking self this summer without having to worry so much about things like whether my toilet would flush. In August I wrote a letter to the editor, published in the local newspaper, that labeled as racists those who fly the Confederate flag and venerate Confederate war “hero” monuments. The Charlotteseville debacle disgusted me, and I felt compelled to speak out. One of the expected responses was a defensive letter about “heritage.”

“I have to ask Ms. Brown, has the Confederate flag ever done anything to you? Were you a slave? Did you pick cotton? Of course not,” the writer argued.

To put it diplomatically, we disagreed. But despite our differences, I considered this exchange a rhetorically significant exercise. It was democracy in action.

I relay this particular story because it provides a decent segue to the question: What is rhetoric, anyway, and why study it?

The definition of rhetoric has actually been debated since Plato’s days. Plato was concerned with getting as close to the absolute truth as possible. He hated that persuasive techniques were being used sans ethical considerations, that people were getting their way even when it was of no benefit to humankind. He therefore considered as hacks people like Gorgias, regarded as the original itinerate teacher of rhetoric. Gorgias developed the craft in Sicily via landowning disputes and took it on the proverbial road to Greece, where the powers that be rapidly found value in it.

In contemporary American society, most of us are inclined to think of rhetoric negatively, as a communicative tool that manipulates or misleads. It is often characterized as divisive and hateful. Rhetoric can be violent, and can even be silent – saying and doing nothing, of course, can actually convey quite a lot, as anyone who has been ghosted knows.

My definition is more liberal, and more akin to something called feminist standpoint theory: I contend that rhetoric is simply communication, intentional or unintentional, that uses symbols to convey meaning. Many of my classmates and instructors, think the craft must embody at least a speck of persuasion. I think it often includes persuasive elements, but not always.

We therefore study and practice rhetoric because it’s essential to understanding ourselves and navigating the world. No matter if we’re frustrated parents cussing like sailors or CEO’s examining ways to maximize ROIs, it helps us make informed decisions, which can ultimately have profound personal and communal effects. Rhetoric is at the core of our conscious lives.

Knowing the rhetorical canons such as audience influence and how to best arrange the information we want to convey, along with recognizing today’s concerns such as digital media delivery methods, translates to power. Critical thought encourages richer perspective and agency. If someone shares a political meme, do you consider its source, the motive for its creation and the context of time? If your child says he has a sore throat, is he getting sick or does he just not want to go to school that day? Did your sister’s eulogy at your mother’s funeral move you to tears?

At any given moment we must contemplate, act upon and produce a number of rhetorically charged messages that influence our lives.

I decided to tackle racists. What’s a recent example of particularly powerful rhetoric that has resonated with you?





Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



From the Blog

Wondering what it's really like to be at The University of Findlay? Follow our bloggers and read—and sometimes listen and watch—their experiences. Real Oilers. Real stories. Real life.

Homestays and new experiences

So far on our journey, we have encountered so many kind people and even made some great new friends. The professors at the University...

Why Fukui?

You may find yourself wondering why we traveled to Japan. To put it simply, Kat and I wholeheartedly believe traveling and immersing yourself in...

Seeing the Sights and Settling In

The first three days of our trip were spent traveling Osaka, a great place for sightseeing here in Japan. We were able to see...

Sleepless in Osaka

A few days ago, we were scheduled to leave for Japan with Dr. Alison Baer and her husband Paul.  If you saw two girls...

Ready to Go!

Hello, Kat Slate and Julia Smith here! We are education majors setting out to teach children, not only here, but all over the world.

We...

Dear Findlay: A Letter to Everyone I’ve Known the Past 4 Years

Dear Findlay (and everyone affiliated),

August 2014, was the beginning of my senior year of high school. For most of my classmates, that meant preparing...

Use Your Words

For my last blog post of the academic year (I’ll be back this fall), I thought I’d provide some educational value to your valuable...

The Senioritis Struggle (or lack thereof): Part 2

Senioritis: sen·ior·i·tis: noun humorous: A supposed affliction of students in their final year of high school or college, characterized by a decline in motivation...

Freshman Year Lessons: An End of the Year Reflection

Looking back on my freshman year at Findlay, I have learned so much. It would be almost impossible to write about how many lessons...

To a New Beginning!

So, it’s almost the end of this semester! Almost the end of me being a freshman! They say time flies. It does.

There are so...

Surviving the End of the Semester: Tips & Tricks

The last few weeks of the semester are always the hardest. Suddenly, everything that you put off because “It isn’t due until the end...

Mazza Museum – Get the Picture!

It’s hard to believe, but not everyone who goes to UF has been to one of my favorite spots on campus: the Mazza Museum. It...

Passionate Students + Humble Leadership + Above & Beyond Mentality = @TheOiler10

On August 19, 2016, Professor Scott Grant, Ed.D., gathered 10 students (including myself) together in Old Main, Room 203. Barely any of us knew...

My Kind of Spring Break

If you are a follower of UFindlay Instagram or my Instagram profile, you may have seen that I had the great opportunity to be...

Let’s Celebrate More Birthdays

More than likely, someone in your life or someone you know has been affected by cancer.

In 2008, when I was just 10 years old,...